Coffee Affection is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Learn more.

Mr. Coffee 12-Cup Coffee Maker Review: 2024 Update

Mr. Coffee 12 Cup Review

Our Final Verdict

We give the Mr. Coffee 12-Cup Coffee Maker a rating of 4.2 out of 5 stars:

Build Quality

Review Summary

Drip coffee brewers are inexpensive and fairly easy to use, helping us brew pots of coffee for families and offices. When it is time to replace your trusty old coffee maker, you can choose from dozens of models. So how does the Mr. Coffee 12-Cup Coffee Maker stack up? We put it to the test.

Our conclusion? If you’re looking for an inexpensive, simple machine, this coffee maker could be for you. It does not offer the extra features of higher-end models, but it’s straightforward, well-priced, and reasonably durable. Mr. Coffee is a well-known brand, and this coffee maker lives up to the name.

Mr. Coffee 12 Cup Coffee Maker – A Quick Look

  • Can make up to 12 cups of coffee
  • Auto-pause lets you start drinking mid-brew
  • Easy to read water window
  • Removable parts (filter basket) make cleaning easy
  • Simple, easy to understand design
  • Very affordable
  • Auto pause doesn’t always work, drips
  • Basic plastic construction
  • Filter basket doesn’t come out easily
Brand: Mr. Coffee
Product Type: Drip coffee maker
Settings: On/Off
Serving size options: 2-12 cups
Color: Black or White
Product dimensions: Height: 12.76″ x Width: 9.1″ x Depth: 11.8″
Product weight : 2.86 pounds
Cord length: 24-26″
Dishwasher-safe parts: Yes
Warranty: 1 year

Overall, this coffee maker is quiet, streamlined, and reliable. Keep reading for a list of our favorite features and a few drawbacks.

Grab-A-Cup Auto Pause

If your mornings are hurried, you’ll love the Grab-A-Cup feature. This allows you to take the coffee pot off the burner before the brewing cycle is finished so you can enjoy a cup whenever you are ready for one. Replace the pot within 30 seconds and it will continue brewing.

Mr. Coffee pouring

Dual Water Window

The dual water window allows you to keep track of the water level in the reservoir. This can help you get the strength of your coffee just right and save you from needing to measure the water you add.

Mr. Coffee water window

Lift & Clean Filter Basket

The filter basket is removable and dishwasher-safe, making it easy to fill and clean. This is a convenient feature because you’ll want to clean your machine regularly. Thorough cleaning will keep the coffee maker running smoothly and the coffee tasting great.

RELATED READ: How to Clean Your Mr. Coffee (Fast & Easy)

Mr. Coffee filter basket

Cord Storage

The cord can be conveniently stored in the back of the machine. The cord itself is short, to prevent tripping hazards.

Mr. Coffee cord storage


We didn’t love every aspect of this coffee maker. It’s entirely made of plastic, which is lightweight but scrapes easily and feels somewhat cheap. The Grab-A-Cup feature is convenient but doesn’t work perfectly. We found that it dripped quite a bit, making a mess on the warming plate.

The drip head also doesn’t extend to the center of the filter basket, so you won’t get perfectly even coffee extraction. Some higher-end models offer shower-style heads that drip evenly across the bed, and you may want to invest in one of those if you’re interested in the best flavor.


Q: Does it have an automatic shut-off?

A: No, this model doesn’t. Make sure you turn it off after you finish the pot.

Q: Does it use a cone or basket-shaped filter?

A: It has a wide filter basket with a flat bottom, compatible with #4 basket filters. Mr. Coffee also sells a permanent coffee filter if you prefer.

Q: Can you brew less than a full pot?

A: Yes. You can brew anywhere between 2 and 12 cups of coffee. Make sure to adjust your coffee grounds measurement and water measurement to stay proportional. About 2-3 tablespoons of coffee should get 6 oz of cold water.

Q: Are there upgrades or other options?

A: Yes. You can upgrade to a programmable model, which will allow you to set a brewing timer. Mr. Coffee also offers a carbon-based water filtration system that you can insert into the filter basket.

divider 6


What’s the bottom line? The Mr. Coffee 12-Cup Coffee Maker could be a good option if you want a simple and affordable machine. It brews up to 12 cups of coffee quickly and quietly and features a straightforward on/off button. This model also comes with a well-designed, sturdy glass carafe and a removable, dishwasher-safe filter basket. There’s an automatic brew pause feature and the water reservoir is easy to fill.

You may be less impressed if you’re looking for an expensive-feeling machine, as the plastic construction feels sturdy but not stylish. This model also lacks features like programmability, strength settings, and evenly extracting shower-heads. But overall, this is a reliable, reasonably compact machine sold at a great price.

Other posts we’ve written about Drip Machines:


Kate MacDonnell

Kate is a lifelong coffee enthusiast and homebrewer who enjoys writing for coffee websites and sampling every kind of coffee known to man. She’s tried unusual coffees from all over the world and owns an unhealthy amount of coffee gear.

Read more

Related posts

Other Categories