Whether you’re shopping for yourself or your favorite coffee-lover, there are many coffee subscriptions out there. A great company will offer you an interesting range of fresh coffee beans delivered straight to your door and may include bonuses like coffee accessories, brewing guides, and detailed origin information. Every coffee subscription service is a little different, so which subscription company should you sign up for?
Don’t worry, we’re here to help you pick a great coffee subscription club. We ordered boxes from the 12 top coffee subscription companies and put together this list of our 10 favorites. For each coffee subscription, we’ve written detailed reviews comparing variety, flavor, freshness, packaging, gift options, and extras so you can choose one that will suit you.
Are you looking for more information? Follow the links under each subscription company to see our comprehensive reviews.
A Quick Look at the Winners of 2021:
|Best Overall||Driftaway Coffee Subscription||
|Best Gift||Angels’ Cup||
|Best Selection||Crema Coffee||
|JavaPresse's Coffee Subscription||
|Best Curation||MistoBox Coffee Subscription||
The 10 Best Coffee Subscriptions:
1. Driftaway Coffee Subscription – Best Overall
Our favorite coffee subscription club is Driftaway Coffee, a stylish, travel-themed club that ships fresh, flavorful beans in thoughtful, convenient packaging. This subscription comes with lots of information, including detailed notes on flavors and coffee origin, and you can contact the farmer directly.
Your subscription starts with a tasting kit offering you four very different flavors. The coffee, which is all single-origin and whole bean, is curated and customized to your preferences. Through a well-designed member portal, you can set your shipping schedule, rate your favorite coffee, and even add a cold-brew subscription.
Driftaway offers great gift subscription options, with personalized, stylish packaging and a great range of flavors. The downside is that this is a pricey subscription, so it may not work for your budget.
Read our full review of Driftaway Coffee here.
2. Angels’ Cup Pod Coffee Subscription – Best Gift
Are you looking for a gift? We recommend Angels’ Cup, which is a fun and stylish subscription club that aims to teach you (or the coffee lover in your life) how to taste and identify coffee like an expert.
Angels’ Cup offers three subscription options, two of which are packaged for blind tasting. You can brew and taste each sample, add your notes on a well-designed app, and then compare your findings with notes from the roaster and your fellow subscribers.
This game-like subscription club sends out challenging, unusual coffee, like a surprisingly delicious Robusta from Thailand and a complex, peppery Ethiopian coffee. This club is curated, so you can’t customize the coffee you receive. Luckily, you can reorder your favorites directly from the roasters. If you don’t like the coffee you receive, Angels’ Cup offers a 100% money-back guarantee.
Want to know more? Take a look at our more detailed review of Angels’ Cup here.
3. Crema Coffee Subscription – Best Selection
If you’re a hands-on shopper, you’ll love Crema, a subscription club that lets you choose every bag of coffee you receive. With a great website, well-designed packaging, and fresh coffee beans, you’ll enjoy shopping for, receiving, and drinking Crema’s coffee.
You can search the Crema website whenever you want, adding types of coffee to your playlist, and Crema will ship them to you based on the schedule you choose. If you don’t know where to start, try the flavor preference quiz, which will direct you to a few great options. The website is fun to explore, with easy sorting and a wide range of available coffee. Once you find your favorite varieties, you can choose to repeat the playlist.
The packaging is stylish, personalized, and conveniently resealable, and the coffee arrives fresh and aromatic. You will have to put in some time shopping for your coffee, as this isn’t a curated subscription, and there aren’t great gift options.
Are you looking for more details? You can find our full review of Crema here.
4. JavaPresse’s Coffee Subscription
JavaPresse is a solid, low-touch option, shipping flavorful whole beans on your schedule. The company ethically sources its coffee from micro-lots, and you have a choice of roast level and shipping frequency.
In addition to being a subscription service, JavaPresse is known for its low-cost, high-quality coffee grinders. If you don’t have a good grinder, this is great news: when you sign up for a subscription, JavaPresse will send you a free manual burr grinder.
JavaPresse’s coffee isn’t especially adventurous or unusual, so it’s a good option if you’re looking for standard, crowd-pleasing flavors. There aren’t any tasting kit or sampler options, and the coffee you receive isn’t customized to your tastes. The packaging is nicely designed but not resealable or personalized.
You can read our complete review of JavaPresse’s subscription here.
5. MistoBox Coffee Subscription – Best Curation
If you’d like expert curation, MistoBox may be an appealing option. When you sign up, MistoBox assigns you a specific curator who will field any questions you have and select coffee that you’ll be likely to enjoy.
It’s up to you, though: you can browse through the website, which offers over 500 coffees from 50 small-batch roasters, and choose your next bag of coffee. If you don’t have time or don’t enjoy shopping, you can leave it in the hands of your expert curator.
The website is well-designed and easy to use, and the packaging is beautiful and personalized. We found the coffee aromatic, fresh, and complex. MistoBox charges shipping fees, and you can’t adjust the bag size or order samples.
6. Trade Coffee Subscription
Are you short on time but still looking for a customized coffee experience? You may enjoy Trade, which uses a flavor quiz and rating system to expertly select coffee you’ll love.
Each shipment includes a note explaining why the company has chosen this coffee for you, based on your preferred brewing method and favorite flavors. The coffee roasts and ships on-demand, so you’re guaranteed to receive fresh, aromatic beans, and there aren’t any shipping fees. Trade offers an easy to use website with a great member portal, and there are cold-brew and ground options.
We received a very interesting Ethiopian coffee with surprising tropical flavors. The packaging was well-designed, and the box included a bingo card that you can play to win a free bag. Trade offers a first match guarantee, meaning that if you don’t like your first bag, they’ll send you another for free.
Curious? Read our complete Trade subscription review here.
7. Larry’s Coffee – Best Eco-Friendly
Are you looking for ethically-sourced, environmentally-friendly coffee? You may want to try Larry’s Coffee, a sustainability-focused company that only sells Organic, Fair Trade, and Shade Grown coffee. Plus, the company offers a range of For-A-Cause blends that benefit a variety of charities.
There isn’t any curation, so you’ll have to choose each bag for yourself. You can order bags from Larry’s Coffee individually, though you’ll save money by setting up a subscription. There won’t be a lot of variety, as each subscription is only for one type of coffee.
Larry’s Coffee doesn’t have particularly nice packaging, but if you’re looking to stock up, it could be a convenient option. We found the coffee tasty and very fresh, with a strong bloom and nice aromas.
You can read our complete review of Larry’s Coffee here.
8. Angelino’s Coffee – Best Pod Coffee
Angelino’s Coffee is a subscription service for pod coffee drinkers. The company sources and small-batch roasts a good range of coffee, packaged in pods that are compatible with Keurig 1.0 and 2.0 brewers.
We found Angelino’s pods flavorful and varied, with interesting, fresh tastes. There are several variety packs, plus decaf, tea, and hot chocolate options, and the company doesn’t charge shipping fees. Angelino’s doesn’t offer curation, and the package doesn’t include very detailed information on tasting notes or origins.
The range of coffee available doesn’t change from month to month, and there aren’t any fun included extras. Angelino’s could be a good option if you’re looking to improve your pod coffee experience, but it isn’t as fun as many other subscriptions and may not make a great gift.
Do you want more information? Read our comprehensive review of Angelino’s Coffee here.
9. Bean Box Subscription
Bean Box is another solid subscription option, offering basic options like bag size, grind size, and roast level. You won’t get to choose your specific coffee, and the coffee isn’t as fresh.
Bean Box doesn’t roast your coffee on-demand, so the beans you’ll receive won’t be as fresh. We found the packaging convenient and fairly well-designed, with resealing bags and detailed tasting notes. We particularly liked the complex, fruity Guatemala Hunapu and the sweet, rich Brazil Canaan Estate, which we received with a recipe for cinnamon syrup and a piece of caramel candy.
Bean Box offers appealing gift options, including chocolate and biscotti pairings. The coffee you receive isn’t customized to your flavor preferences, though the website is easy to use, with a useful member portal.
You can read our more detailed review of Bean Box here.
10. Match Made – Best Pairing Subscription
If you have a sweet tooth, you may appreciate Match Made’s coffee subscription club, which pairs freshly-baked cookies with its coffee selections. This company falls at the end of our list because its coffee, which is only sold pre-ground, doesn’t arrive as fresh or flavorful, and you can’t customize the schedule.
To order a Match Made box, you have to put in your order by the 15th of each month, and the company ships to all of its subscribers toward the end of the month. With your subscription, you’ll receive two small samples of medium-ground coffee, paired with two individually-packaged cookies. All of the coffee is Organic and single-origin.
The coffee and cookies you receive aren’t personalized to your tastes, and there aren’t any gluten-free, nut-free, or decaffeinated coffee options. The cookies are a tasty addition, pairing well with full-bodied, interesting coffee from all over the world.
Want to know more about Match Made? Read our full review here.
Now that you’ve seen our list of the best coffee subscription services, it’s time to try one for yourself. But with so many great options, which should you choose? Keep reading for our guide to choosing the best subscription for your needs.
Curation and Customization
Would you like to choose your next coffee from an extensive list or let an expert do the choosing for you? Subscription services offer a range of curation levels. With some, you won’t have to make any decisions, while others will offer you the choice of hundreds of varieties.
When you get started with a subscription, many will offer you a preference quiz, which will help the company learn what brewing methods, roast levels, and flavors you like. After that, they’ll either offer you suggested bags of coffee or send that information over to an algorithm or real curator to do the choosing.
If you’re short on time or hate shopping, you may prefer a company that will choose each bag for you. Some even offer you a dedicated curator! If you’d like to have more control over the coffee you receive, you may prefer a company that will let you shop for each bag and provide you with plenty of tasting and origin notes.
Do you need coffee on a specific schedule? Many of the companies we reviewed allow you to fully customize your coffee schedule. Through their websites, you can change dates and pause or cancel shipments.
Some, like Match Made, ship on a set schedule that you can’t adjust. For these companies, you’ll need to place your order by a specific date to receive that month’s box.
Packaging and Design
Is nicely-designed packaging a priority for you? This may be especially important if you’re giving a subscription as a gift. The companies we reviewed offer a wide range of styles and designs, from travel-themed Driftaway to mysterious Angels’ Cup.
The other aspect of packaging is how practical it is. Do the coffee bags have one-way degassing valves and resealing tops? These features can help you keep your beans fresh without needing a separate storage container.
Whole Bean vs. Ground
Do you have a grinder, or do you prefer to buy pre-ground beans? Ground coffee beans are undeniably convenient, though you’ll need to get the right grind size for your preferred brewing method. Some coffee subscriptions offer you a range of grind sizes, from a fine espresso grind to a coarse French press.
Coffee starts to lose flavor just 15 minutes after you grind it, so you’ll get the best flavor if you buy whole bean coffee and grind it just before brewing. For this reason, many high-quality coffee subscription companies only sell whole bean coffee. The good news? There’s a great coffee grinder out there for you, no matter what your budget is. Plus, if you sign up for JavaPresse, they’ll send you a free manual burr grinder!
Are you looking for a grinder? Take a look at our guide to the best burr grinders on the market.
How much coffee do you drink every week? Many subscription companies will offer you a choice of bag sizes or number of bags so that you can fully stock up.
Whether you buy them for yourself or a friend, coffee subscriptions are a fun treat. Depending on which you choose, they may come with extras like freshly baked cookies, detailed roasting, origin, and flavor notes, or personalized messages.
One of our favorite extras was the sampler option. Companies like Driftaway and Bean Box start your subscription by sending samplers with four very different beans. You sample and rate each variety, and the coffee you receive in the future is based on your preferences. For an adventurous twist, try Angels’ Cup, which offers blind tasting.
The results are in, and it’s time to start shopping! Our top pick is Driftaway Coffee, a travel-themed subscription that starts with a tasting kit and customizes every coffee to your favorite flavors. If you’re shopping for a gift, we recommend Angels’ Cup, which challenges your taste buds with blind tastings of unconventional coffee. If you’re a big shopper, Crema could be for you, with a well-designed website offering a huge number of coffee varieties. Would you rather let the experts do the shopping? Try MistoBox, a stylish, customized subscription that pairs you with a curator.
Are you looking for sustainable, eco-friendly coffee? You may prefer Larry’s Coffee, a roaster with a great selection of coffee with Organic, Fair Trade, and many other certifications, plus signature For-A-Cause blends. Do you drink pod coffee? Try Angelino’s Coffee, a small-batch roaster offering fresh, flavorful pods in a great range of varieties. And if you’re interested in coffee pairings, you may want to look at Match Made, a subscription service that sends out single-origin coffee matched with freshly-baked cookies.
With all of these great subscriptions, there’s quite a lot to sort through. We hope this list of the 10 best coffee subscriptions, complete with detailed reviews, helps you pick a great company. Whether you’re looking for blind tastings or cookie pairings, there’s a delicious coffee subscription waiting for you.
Table of Contents
- A Quick Look at the Winners of 2021:
- The 10 Best Coffee Subscriptions:
- 1. Driftaway Coffee Subscription – Best Overall
- 2. Angels’ Cup Pod Coffee Subscription – Best Gift
- 3. Crema Coffee Subscription – Best Selection
- 4. JavaPresse’s Coffee Subscription
- 5. MistoBox Coffee Subscription – Best Curation
- 6. Trade Coffee Subscription
- 7. Larry’s Coffee – Best Eco-Friendly
- 8. Angelino’s Coffee – Best Pod Coffee
- 9. Bean Box Subscription
- 10. Match Made – Best Pairing Subscription
- Buyer’s Guide